Farmers Co-Op Lawsuit Alleges Improper Excessive Pay and Perks for Former Top Executives and a Mistress

If allegations are true in a lawsuit filed against a former leader of a Midwest farmers co-operative, his wife, board chairman, and legal counsel, they could provide plenty of material for a Netflix drama that could captivate an audience for hours. But the victims of these allegations could be farmers and their families unless the court can recover misspent money.
Landus Cooperative, based in Des Moines, Iowa, is suing former President/CEO Matthew Carstens, Shanda Carstens, former board chair Matthews Chambers, and former executive vice president/general counsel Stephen Nielsen.
Landus represents more than 5,500 farmers in Iowa and nearby states.
What Does the Lawsuit Allege About the Landus CEO’s Pay?
The lawsuit alleges that Matthew Carstens misled the board as he carried out a scheme that inflated his pay nearly seven-fold as it went from $625,000 to $4.4 million.
It claims that Matthew and Shanda Carstens had full-time staff, at Landus' expense, that catered to their personal needs, which included placing Ritz crackers and ginger ale by the couple's bedroom recliners, fluffing furniture cushions in the living room, and making sure that Matthew Carstens' robe and slippers were in their designated places by the bed and his heated blanket was "tucked in."
The lawsuit alleges that board members weren't aware of a plan to commit Landus funds to pay for the Carstens' $3.5 million home in a Des Moines suburb, a wellness retreat on their property, or a $10 million beachfront mansion near Tampa, Florida.
It also states that board members did not previously know that the Carstens used the company's plane for vacation.
Matthew Carstens also had a mistress, the lawsuit claims, that he had convinced Landus to hire. The lawsuit contends that the board could not figure out what the woman did to justify a $280,000 salary and severance payment.
The court filing claims that Nielsen and Chambers assisted Carstens in his plans to deceive the company.
The filing requests judgement against the accused but does not specify total payment.
Landus Cooperative Responds to Lawsuit
"This is not a decision the BOD (Board of Directors) and Landus leadership made lightly," Landus Cooperative said in a statement. "A stepwise and thorough investigation over the last year revealed misconduct by the defendants, for which we believe we have a moral and ethical responsibility to pursue claims."
The statement also laid out how Landus will have better oversight in the future:
"Over the past year, the Landus BOD has taken significant steps to strengthen how the Cooperative is governed. These changes were not simply management initiatives. The BOD has actively sought greater transparency, stronger financial oversight and clearer accountability. These improvements are designed to protect the Cooperative and ensure its leadership remains responsible to the farmers who own it."
The lawsuit did not include a response from the accused.
American Farmland Owners has previously reported on Landus Cooperative's previous financial challenges and leadership changes.
RELATED: In 2024, Landus Cooperative Regional Sales Manager Matt Brown, who is not the subject of any wrongdoing in the lawsuit against former executives, explained the benefits of a new fertilizer commitment.






